| Print article | This entry was posted by Sonia Lawrence on December 14, 2011 at 8:36 am, and is filed under (New) in Print, Commentary, Reblogged, What we're thinking/reading/doing (IFLS blog). Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |
No comments yet.
No trackbacks yet.
Eric & Lola Roundtable (actually, let’s call it Quebec v. A): Margot Young on Consent, sexism, ignorance and gender
about 1 week ago - No comments
All the posts in our Eric & Lola AKA Quebec (Attorney General) v. A, 2013 SCC 5 roundtable can be found HERE. Thanks to Simon Fodden over at slaw.ca for the shout out for this roundtable – who knew that there were readers! Sonia asked: Can we read this case, and the reaction of…
Eric & Lola Roundtable: Robert Leckey on political sensitivities in the application of Oakes
about 2 weeks ago - No comments
All the posts in our Eric & Lola AKA Quebec (Attorney General) v. A, 2013 SCC 5 roundtable can be found HERE. Sonia asked: Can we read this case, and the reaction of the Supreme Court, as more or equally “a case about Quebec” than an “ordinary” Charter challenge, that is, a case…
Eric & Lola Roundtable: Hester Lessard on Democratic Engagement, and Hauntings
about 2 weeks ago - No comments
All the posts in our Eric & Lola AKA Quebec (Attorney General) v. A, 2013 SCC 5 roundtable can be found HERE. Sonia asked: Can we read this case, and the reaction of the Supreme Court, as more or equally “a case about Quebec” than an “ordinary” Charter challenge, that is, a case…
Eric & Lola Roundtable: Leckey Responds
about 3 weeks ago - No comments
All the posts in our Eric & Lola AKA Quebec (Attorney General) v. A, 2013 SCC 5 roundtable can be found HERE. Robert Leckey responds May 28: I think that Margot, by agreeing with LeBel J. (on one thing, at least), overstates the irony of Abella J.’s invocation of opting-out. Opting-in and opting-out…
Eric & Lola Roundtable: Margot Young on Packages, Icebergs & Legal Liberalism
about 4 weeks ago - No comments
All the posts in our Eric & Lola AKA Quebec (Attorney General) v. A, 2013 SCC 5 roundtable can be found HERE. Margot Young: Robert’s comments illustrate well the failure of judges other than those signed on to Justice Abella’s judgment to “open the box”—that is to unwrap the package of marriage law…
Eric & Lola Roundtable: Robert Leckey responds on choice
about 1 month ago - No comments
All the posts in our Eric & Lola AKA Quebec (Attorney General) v. A, 2013 SCC 5 roundtable can be found HERE. Robert Leckey: Hester has nicely set out the different takes on choice (see below for Hester Lessard’s post). Wearing my hat as a Quebec family lawyer, what disappoints me is that the…
Eric & Lola Roundtable: Hester Lessard – Knotted & Glued
about 1 month ago - No comments
Thanks everyone for that first round – thanks a lot. I’m more worried than I was before! Your comments were not comforting, except in the sense of confirming some of my fears. Why can’t we recognize this is gendered (Margot)? Where is the discussion about stereotyping going (Robert)? Is Abella J’s strong section 15 position…
[Eric & Lola Roundtable] Margot Young: Liberty with a Vengeance
about 1 month ago - No comments
Sonia: So, do you think that this case sets up a new approach to section 15 (again)? What’ significant about the way that the section 15 analyses are carried out, compared to previous cases and the divergent decisions in this case? What about the approach to the “line” between section 15 and section 1? All…
[Eric & Lola (3)] Robert Leckey: What they say v What they do
about 1 month ago - No comments
Sonia: So, do you think that this case sets up a new approach to section 15 (again)? What’ significant about the way that the section 15 analyses are carried out, compared to previous cases and the divergent decisions in this case? What about the approach to the “line” between section 15 and section 1? All…
Eric v Lola: an online roundtable
about 1 month ago - No comments
We’re excited to introduce the first IFLS roundtable, designed to make a space for legal scholars to have important & timely conversations without the formality of peer review, yet still allow them more control over content than direct engagement with traditional media often does. Hope you enjoy it! When the decision in Eric v Lola,…

Leckey likes Monk (lots!) at jotwell equality: The Problem of (condemning) Homophobic Bullying
Even as we celebrate the news that the UN Sec’y General has said that homophobic bullying is a grave human rights violation,
can i urge you all to take a look at Robert Leckey’s review of Daniel Monk (Birkbeck), Challenging Homophobic Bullying in Schools: The Politics of Progress, 7 (2) Int’l J. L. Context 181 (2011at Jotwell Equality? And then of course, read the original article here (not available free of charge as far as I can tell, curses! *tangent: see Danah Boyd’s excellent and important ‘rant’ on academic publishing here)? Leckey writes approvingly (inter alia) of Monk’s “counterintuitive” argument that: